Bill Schaff
Writ 1133
Professor Leake
May 6, 2013
MSG
When I got to
thinking about the last meal that I have eaten, I started thinking about why
some foods have more intense flavors than others. Especially when it comes to
non-natural foods such as chips and deserts. In doing some research, I found
out that there is actually an ingredient that companies use to intensify the
flavors in food. The ingredient is called MSG.
Monosodium
glutamate, or MSG or (S)-glutamic acid, was first discovered in 1866 by a chemist
named Ritthausen. During this time, Ritthausen did not know what MSG did. What
he accomplished was discovering it glutamic acid. It was not until 1908 that we
found out what the glutamic acid was used for. At this time, a Japanese chemist
named Kikunae Ikeda identified MSG’s as a flavor enhancing substance. He did so
by extracting it out of kelp like seaweed called Konbu. The method he used to
do so was by boiling 40 kilograms of seaweed and got 30 grams of (S)-glutamic
acid. Ikeda identified this as the flavor enhancing part of Konbu (Kauffman,
347). Since 1908, this glutamic acid, which is apart of the amino acid group,
has become a regular part of modern day societies and is used widely in many
different kind of foods.
As for the
production of amino acids, there are four main ways that are typically used to
obtain the acids. They are: extraction from natural sources, chemical
synthesis, fermentation, and enzymatic catalysis. Of the four ways, on
fermentation is used when obtaining the (S)-glutamic acid, or MSG (Kauffman, 347).
The actual process of fermentation is one that should only be understood by a
chemistry major, but The Encyclopedia of
Common Natural Ingredients does a good job of explaining it:
Currently most of
the world production of [monosodium glutamate] is by bacterial fermentation. In
this method bacteria (especially strains of Micrococcus glutamicus) are
grown aerobically in a liquid nutrient medium containing a carbon source (e.g.,
dextrose or citrate), a nitrogen source such as ammonium ions or urea, and
mineral ions and growth factors. The bacteria selected for this process have
the ability to excrete glutamic acid they synthesize outside of their cell
membrane into the medium and accumulate there. The glutamic acid is separated
from the fermentation broth by filtration, concentration, acidification, and
crystallization, followed by conversion to its monosodium salt [monosodium
glutamate] (Leung, 373).
There
are a number of different ways that MSGs are put into food products but most
consist of one of three ways. First in spraying, after the food has been
produced the company will spray a layer of MSG onto it in order to enhance the
taste or the company can spray it onto the food during the growing phases. An
example is wine, people will spray the grapes with MSG while they are still on
the vine. This method is not as common as the other two methods. The second
method is through basting and injecting. While cooking the food, chefs can pour
juices that contain MSGs over the meat to keep it moist or inject it directly
with MSGs to enhance the flavor. The third way is through the crops being grown.
Companies can add MSGs to the fertilizers used in growing the crops (History
and Invention). There are many other ways but these are the main three that are
used in todays society.
Throughout
researching the history and production of MSG, what I really learned is that it
can be made without using a lab. What I mean by this is that it can be
extracted from things in nature. I always thought that MSG, like many food
enhancements, was something that we created in a lab to be added into our foods
but I was pleasantly surprised to be wrong about this. While yes the way that
we acquire MSG for our food production is through the lad, it was discovered in
something natural. The other thing that I have learned about MSG is the many
different ways that it can be added to foods. Coming into this, I thought that
MSG was only added after the food had been made. For example, Dorito chips has
a layer of something on them and I thought that something was MSG.
Knowing
what I now know about MSG, it actually helps my relationship with the
ingredient. Looking only at the history and production, not health concerns
because it is very bad for you, it was found in a natural substance and not
engineered in a lab. I like this because to me, something that is natural is
better for you. I believe that natural things can be digested easier and have
less risks to them than things that are created in a lab. I’m not sure if this
is right or wrong but it is what I believe. Also, another reason that I like it
better after researching it is because there are natural glutamic acids found
in our bodies. The way that I see it, if it is already in our body how can it
be bad for you?
Works
Cited
"History of invention and use of
MSG." Truth in Labeling. N.p., n.d. Web. 7 May 2013.
<http://www.truthinlabeling.org/IVhistoryOfUse.html>.
Kauffman, George B. "Chemistry is For
Everyone." Journal of Chemical Education 81.3 (2004): 347-55.
Web. 7 May 2013. <http://www.cornellcollege.edu/chemistry/cstrong/512/msg.pdf>.
Leung, A. and Foster, S. Encyclopedia
of Common Natural Ingredients Used in Food, Drugs , and Cosmetics.
New York: Wiley, 1996. pp 373-375
The main points of this essay were giving a brief history of MSG (who discovered it and how it came to "be"), discussing how it is produced, what it is used for, and the different ways it can be used.
ReplyDeleteEncyclopedia information is incorporated into this essay, along with journals providing additional information about MSG and the history behind it. I thought the sources were effectively quoted and used in an appropriate manner.
It seems the author's "relationship" with MSG has only gotten better since writing this essay. He writes that to him, if it is natural it is better for you.
The only thing I can think of for revision would be that there are some words that are added and don't really need to be included in the sentences, but that is just a personal preference. Other than that, good paper!
This is a very interesting essay and I enjoyed learning about the history and production of MSG. In the first body paragraph you did a good job of discussing the history of MSG and how over time it developed into something more than just a substance but rather something that we use on a daily basis. Furthermore, as the essay progressed you began to discuss how MSG is used in the foods we eat and drink and it was interesting to see how MSG plays such a big part in the things we eat.
ReplyDeleteThe research that you did like using the Encyclopedia of Common Natural Ingredients did a good job in explaining the actual process of fermentation. The placement is good and you do a good job of introducing the quote and tying it into what you are talking about.
It appears to me that your relationship with MSG is a bit better know because you where pleasantly surprised with how it is extracted and the production of it and that now you have an improved relationship with it.